In the previous article, I discussed the idea of technological affordances, the unique possibilities that digital tools offer for learning. Understanding the affordances of a technology helps us decide when a particular tool genuinely adds value to a lesson. However, recognizing what technology can do is only half of the equation. Equally important is recognizing when technology is being used simply because it is available.
This is what I refer to as the technology-for-technology trap.
The trap occurs when the starting point for lesson planning becomes the software rather than the learning objective. Instead of asking, What do I want my students to learn?, we begin by asking, What can this application do? It is an understandable mistake. Institutions encourage instructors to make greater use of Learning Management Systems (LMSs), publishers continually add new digital features to their textbooks, and new AI-powered tools appear almost weekly. Under these circumstances, it is easy to assume that using more technology automatically leads to better learning.
Research over the past two decades suggests otherwise. As Selwyn (2016) argues, educational technology should never be viewed as an inherently transformative force. Its effectiveness depends almost entirely on how it is integrated into teaching and learning. Likewise, Hattie (2023) reminds us that technology itself has only a modest impact on student achievement. What matters most is the quality of the teaching that surrounds it.
I can certainly sympathize with the temptation. I have always considered myself something of a “techie.” I enjoy exploring new software, experimenting with websites, and keeping up with developments in artificial intelligence and educational technology. It is one of the aspects of my profession that I genuinely enjoy. At the same time, experience has taught me that enthusiasm for technology can easily cloud professional judgement. Whenever I discover a promising new tool, I have learned to pause before introducing it into the classroom. The first question should never be, How can I use this? Instead, it should be, Will this improve learning in ways that would otherwise be difficult or impossible?
Just Because the Tool Exists Doesn’t Mean It Should Be Used
Learning Management Systems provide a useful example. Most modern LMS platforms include built-in quiz generators that make it remarkably easy to create multiple-choice, true-or-false, matching, and fill-in-the-blank activities. Digital textbooks often include similar functions. Because these features already exist, they are frequently incorporated into courses with very little reflection. After all, creating a twenty-question online quiz requires only a few minutes, and the system grades it automatically.
Convenience, however, should never be mistaken for effective pedagogy.
Readers who have followed this blog will know that I have often questioned traditional language learning activities when they are used simply because they are familiar. Converting those same activities into digital format does not automatically improve them. Replacing a paper worksheet with an online quiz may make a course appear more modern, but it does not necessarily increase the quality of learning. Mayer’s (2021) research on multimedia learning reinforces this point. Learning is influenced far more by instructional design than by the medium through which information is delivered.
This is not to suggest that quizzes have no place in language education. Low-stakes quizzes can provide useful formative assessment, identify misconceptions, and help learners monitor their own progress. The problem arises when quizzes become an end in themselves rather than one component of a broader learning process. Students may appear busy as they work through question after question, but activity should never be confused with engagement.
Turning Students into Assessment Designers
One relatively simple adjustment can transform this familiar activity. Rather than asking students to complete a quiz, ask them to design one.
I have used this approach with learners at a variety of proficiency levels, and the results have consistently surprised me. Instead of passively answering questions, students become responsible for creating them. Their role shifts from consumers of assessment to designers of assessment. This subtle change dramatically alters the level of thinking required.
One workflow that has worked particularly well begins with individual preparation. Students are assigned the task of writing several quiz questions based on recently studied material before coming to class. During the following lesson, they meet in small groups to compare, critique, and improve their questions. As they work, the discussion naturally shifts toward broader issues. What makes a multiple-choice question effective? What makes a distractor plausible? Which language points are important enough to assess? How difficult should the questions be?
Rather than supplying the answers, I encourage each group to develop its own criteria before we compare ideas as a class. Together, we construct a simple rubric describing the characteristics of an effective quiz question. Students then revise their original work or create entirely new questions using the rubric they have helped develop.
At this point, the atmosphere in the classroom usually changes noticeably. Conversations become animated as students debate grammar, vocabulary, wording, and the fairness of individual questions. They frequently challenge one another’s assumptions and begin asking questions that rarely emerge during conventional review activities. In many ways, the assignment quietly accomplishes what every language instructor hopes for. To create meaningful assessment questions, students must first develop a solid understanding of the material themselves.
This observation is consistent with research on formative assessment. Nicol and Macfarlane-Dick (2006) argue that students learn more effectively when they actively participate in assessment rather than simply receiving it. Similarly, Wiliam (2011) emphasizes that assessment should be viewed as part of learning rather than merely a method of measuring it. By asking learners to generate assessment tasks, we encourage analysis, discussion, reflection, and self-regulation instead of simple recall.
Let Technology Support the Learning
Technology can then play a valuable supporting role. Once groups have produced high-quality questions, they can use Google Forms or another online platform to build their quizzes and share them with classmates. The technology makes distribution, feedback, and discussion easier, but it does not create the learning. The learning has already taken place through the collaborative process of designing the assessment itself.
This distinction may appear subtle, but it represents an important shift in thinking. The digital tool is no longer driving the lesson. Instead, it amplifies an activity that already possesses educational value. Biggs and Tang’s (2011) principle of constructive alignment reminds us that teaching activities should always be selected because they support intended learning outcomes, not because they happen to be available within a particular piece of software.
Final Thoughts
Educational technology continues to evolve at an astonishing pace. Artificial intelligence, adaptive learning systems, immersive virtual environments, and countless new applications will undoubtedly become part of our classrooms over the coming years. Many of these innovations deserve serious attention, and some will undoubtedly improve learning in meaningful ways. Nevertheless, the fundamental question remains unchanged.
When evaluating any new technology, I try to avoid asking only what the software can do. Instead, I begin by asking what kind of thinking I want my students to engage in. Only after answering that question do I consider whether technology has a meaningful role to play.
Good technology cannot rescue weak pedagogy. At its best, however, it can amplify good pedagogy and make powerful learning experiences even more effective. If we remember that principle, we are far less likely to fall into the technology-for-technology trap.
Questions worth asking
1. Why am I using this technology?
2. What thinking does this activity require?
3. If I removed the technology, would the learning still be valuable?
4. Could students take greater ownership?
5. What is the technology actually adding?
References
Biggs, J., & Tang, C. (2011). Teaching for quality learning at university (4th ed.). Open University Press.
Hattie, J. (2023). Visible learning: The sequel. Routledge.
Mayer, R. E. (2021). Multimedia learning (3rd ed.). Cambridge University Press.
Nicol, D. J., & Macfarlane‐Dick, D. (2006). Formative assessment and self‐regulated learning: A model and seven principles of good feedback practice. Studies in Higher Education, 31(2), 199-218.
Selwyn, N. (2016). Education and technology: Key issues and debates (2nd ed.). Bloomsbury Academic.
Wiliam, D. (2011). Embedded formative assessment. Solution Tree Press.






Leave a Reply