Why teachers should think carefully before adopting digital platforms
In the previous post, I argued that technology is neither inherently good nor inherently bad. The real question is whether we are using digital tools thoughtfully. Learning management systems (LMS) provide a good example of why this matters.
Most teachers today work with some form of LMS. Whether it is Moodle, Google Classroom, Microsoft Teams, Canvas, Blackboard, or a proprietary university system, these platforms have become a normal part of educational life. We use them to distribute materials, collect assignments, communicate with students, record grades, provide feedback, and organise course content. In theory, they should make teaching easier and more efficient.
In practice, the situation is often more complicated.
Over the years, I have become increasingly interested in a simple question whenever I encounter a new educational technology: is it worth the investment? Every new system requires time and effort. Teachers must learn how it works, students must learn how to use it, and both sides must deal with the inevitable frustrations that appear whenever technology enters the picture. Sometimes that investment pays off. Sometimes it does not.
The challenge is not deciding whether to use technology. Most of us no longer have that choice. The more important challenge is learning how to evaluate it.
The LMS Problem Nobody Talks About
After teaching at several universities in Japan, I have lost count of the number of learning management systems I have been required to learn. What makes the experience particularly frustrating is that many of them look almost identical.
Roughly ninety percent of the interface feels familiar. This encourages teachers and students to assume they already know how the system works. Then they discover that the remaining ten percent has been reorganised just enough to make simple tasks surprisingly difficult. Assignment submission is hidden under a different menu. Grades are accessed through a different screen. Course materials are organised differently. A task that should take thirty seconds suddenly takes ten minutes.
The result is an interesting paradox. These systems are supposed to reduce administrative burdens yet learning how to navigate them often becomes an administrative burden itself.
My experience in Japan has also highlighted another issue. Although Japan is often associated with advanced technology, educational software can sometimes feel surprisingly dated. During my doctoral research, I wrote about how early discussions of Information and Communications Technology(ICT) in Japan often emphasised the technological aspects of implementation while paying less attention to communication, usability, and pedagogy. While much has improved over the years, there are still moments when educational software feels as though it was designed with the priorities of administrators rather than the needs of teachers and students in mind.
None of this means that LMS platforms are inherently bad. Many of them perform important functions very well. The lesson is simply that we should not assume that a digital solution is automatically an improvement.
Ease of Use Matters More Than We Think
One of the theories that shaped my doctoral research was Davis’s (1989) Technology Acceptance Model. The framework proposes that two factors strongly influence whether people adopt a technology: perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use.
The idea sounds almost obvious. If people find something useful and easy to use, they are more likely to embrace it. If they find it confusing, frustrating, or unnecessarily complicated, they will avoid it whenever possible.
Yet educational institutions often overlook this point.
A system may have dozens of advanced features, but if students struggle to find their assignments or teachers spend hours figuring out how to configure basic functions, those features become far less valuable. Sometimes the most effective tool is not the most powerful one. It is the one that allows people to accomplish their goals with the fewest obstacles.
This is one reason why I have generally had positive experiences with platforms such as Google Classroom and Microsoft Teams. They are not perfect, but they are built around tools that students are already likely to encounter elsewhere. Students learn how to work with documents, spreadsheets, presentations, calendars, and collaborative workspaces. The software serves a purpose beyond a single course.
That is not always true of proprietary university systems.
The Return on Investment Question
Whenever I introduce a new digital tool, I try to ask myself a simple question: will students ever use this again?
If the answer is no, I need a very good reason for requiring them to learn it.
Every hour students spend learning software is an hour they are not spending learning course content, practising skills, or engaging with their classmates. That does not mean learning software is a waste of time. Far from it. Many digital skills are incredibly valuable. The key issue is whether the investment produces benefits that extend beyond a single assignment or course.
This is one reason I often favour tools that develop transferable skills. Learning how to use presentation software, collaborative documents, spreadsheets, or project management tools has value that extends beyond an English class. Students may use these applications in other courses, internships, part-time jobs, and eventually full-time employment.
The same logic applies to teachers. If I spend several hours learning a platform, I want to know that the knowledge will remain useful. One of the frustrations of educational technology is that platforms appear and disappear with remarkable speed. Teachers invest time mastering a system only to discover that it has been discontinued, redesigned, or replaced a few years later.
Many educators have experienced this cycle.
The goal, therefore, is not to find the perfect LMS. The goal is to find systems that support learning while staying out of the way.
Affordances Matter More Than Features
One concept that has become increasingly important to me over the years is affordances.
Gibson (1979) originally used the term to describe the possibilities for action that an environment or object provides. Later, Norman (1988) adapted the concept for design and usability, helping popularise the idea that effective tools should make desired actions intuitive and accessible to users. In educational settings, affordances encourage us to focus less on what a tool is designed to do and more on what it actually allows teachers and students to accomplish. This distinction is more important than it may initially appear.
Many discussions of educational technology focus on features. Companies advertise dozens of functions, integrations, dashboards, analytics systems, and customisation options. However, having more features does not necessarily improve learning unless those features actually address real problems.
During the COVID period, I experimented with several platforms for online teaching. Google Hangouts never worked particularly well for my purposes, especially when I wanted students working in small groups. Zoom’s breakout rooms made online interaction significantly easier. Later, when I had to use Teams more extensively, its integrated breakout-room functions solved many of the same problems.
The lesson was not that one platform was universally better than another. The lesson was that different tools offered different affordances, and those affordances needed to match the goals of the lesson.
The same principle applies to learning management systems. Assignment collection, feedback, deadline reminders, collaborative documents, and shared workspaces often provide genuine value, but other features may require significant setup while offering relatively little benefit in return. Rather than asking what a system can do, it is often more useful to ask what it allows students and teachers to do better.
Beware Technology for Technology’s Sake
One of the easiest traps to fall into is using a feature simply because it exists.
Quiz builders provide a good example. Most LMS make it relatively easy to create multiple-choice, true-false, or fill-in-the-blank activities. However, moving these question types online does not automatically improve learning. In many cases, the digital version reproduces the same strengths and weaknesses as the paper version.
A more interesting approach might be to have students create quiz questions themselves. Doing so requires them to identify key concepts, think about how knowledge is assessed, and consider what makes a good question. In this case, the learning comes from creating the questions rather than from the technology being used. Students can spend the time interacting with classmates discussing their comprehension of the lesson material to produce content instead of staring at a screen pushing buttons by themselves minutes before the assignment deadline.
This is not an argument against quizzes. It is a reminder that technology should support pedagogy rather than dictate it.
The same principle applies whenever we encounter a new application. Before introducing it to students, it is worth asking what educational purpose it serves. If the answer is simply that it looks impressive or happens to be available, it may be worth reconsidering.
Not Every Tool Needs to Be Serious
At this point, it may sound as though every technology decision should be based entirely on efficiency and productivity. While those considerations are important, they are not the only things that matter.
Sometimes a tool is worth using because it encourages creativity, ownership, or simply makes an activity more engaging.
Over the years, I have occasionally allowed students to use applications such as Pixton or Plotagon to create comics and short animated conversations. These projects were usually offered as optional activities or opportunities for bonus credit rather than core assignments.
From a purely efficiency-based perspective, there are certainly faster ways to practise dialogue writing. However, students often became far more invested in the activity because they could visualise conversations, create characters, and bring their ideas to life. For some students who would probably never have discovered the applications on their own, the technology supported imagination and personal expression in ways that traditional exercises sometimes struggle to achieve.
Not every classroom decision needs to be justified through productivity. Creativity and engagement are legitimate educational goals as well.
The important point is that the technology should serve a purpose rather than becoming the purpose.
Looking Beyond English Class
One of the most useful questions teachers can ask when evaluating educational technology is whether students will be able to use the skill elsewhere.
If a platform disappeared tomorrow, what would remain?
Ideally, students would still possess stronger writing skills, better organisational habits, improved collaboration abilities, and greater digital literacy. Those outcomes are far more valuable than mastery of any one specific application.
This is why I often encourage students to develop skills that extend beyond language learning. Learning how to create effective presentations, manage shared documents, edit video or audio, organise research materials, and collaborate online may require additional effort, but these are skills that can continue to provide value long after a course has ended. Technology changes quickly but the underlying skills that well-chosen technology affords tend to last much longer.
Reflection Before Adoption
Learning management systems are now part of modern education, and many of them provide genuine benefits. They can simplify communication, streamline assignment submission, support collaboration, and help students stay organised.
At the same time, they should not be adopted uncritically. As Selwyn (2016) argues, educational technologies should be examined within their social and institutional contexts rather than being assumed to be transformative simply because they are digital.
Before introducing a new system, I try to think about the problem it solves, the effort required to learn it, and whether students will gain any skill or benefit from the system they can use beyond my course. This reflects a broader principle in educational technology: effective teaching depends not simply on access to technology, but on how technological choices interact with pedagogy and content knowledge (Mishra & Koehler, 2006). I also consider its affordances and whether the return on investment justifies the time required from both students and teachers.
These questions do not guarantee perfect decisions, but they encourage a more thoughtful approach to educational technology.
Ultimately, the value of an LMS should not be determined by the number of features it offers or the sophistication of its interface. What matters is whether it helps teachers and students achieve meaningful goals more effectively than the alternatives. Technology should support learning, not become another obstacle standing in its way.
References
Davis, F. D. (1989). Perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, and user acceptance of information technology. MIS Quarterly, 13(3), 319–340.
Gibson, J. J. (1979). The ecological approach to visual perception. Houghton Mifflin.
Norman, D. A. (1988). The psychology of everyday things. Basic Books.
Mishra, P., & Koehler, M. J. (2006). Technological pedagogical content knowledge: A framework for teacher knowledge. Teachers College Record, 108(6), 1017–1054.
Selwyn, N. (2016). Education and technology: Key issues and debates (2nd ed.). Bloomsbury.






Leave a Reply