What Japanese Students Don’t Learn After 12 Years of Formal Education

What Japanese Students Don’t Learn After 12 Years of Formal Education

Introduction: The Problem We Do Not See

After over 15 years teaching university students in Japan, particularly first-year students, I notice something that still surprises me. It is not simply what students do not know. It is what they were never taught how to do. Like numerous teachers, I initially assumed that students entering university would already possess a basic set of academic skills, including the ability to brainstorm ideas, organize them, summarize information, and apply what they have learned in new contexts. These are not advanced competencies. They are foundational.

However, after also spending more than six years teaching high school in Japan, a consistent pattern became clear. Many students have never been explicitly taught how to generate ideas, how to develop them, how to evaluate them, or how to shape them into structured communication. This gap is not limited to English. It affects learning more broadly. In many cases, it may be one of the main reasons learning, especially language learning, feels so difficult and, at times, unproductive.


The Core Issue: A Missing Process, Not a Lack of Ability

It is important to clarify what this argument is and what it is not. This is not a question of intelligence, nor is it primarily a question of motivation. When I say that students struggle to “think,” I am not referring to abstract cognitive ability. Rather, I am referring to something much more practical: the learned ability to generate multiple ideas, consider possible outcomes, and organize those ideas into a coherent structure that can be communicated.

These are procedural skills, and like any skill, they require explicit instruction and repeated practice. Educational research has long distinguished surface learning, which emphasizes memorization and repetition, and deep learning, which involves understanding, connection, and application (Biggs & Tang, 2011). What I have consistently observed is that many students have been trained almost exclusively in surface-level strategies. As a result, when they are asked to produce, whether in English or even in their first language, they often lack the underlying processes needed to do so effectively.


You Cannot Organize Ideas You Do Not Have

One insight helps to unify many of these observations. You cannot organize ideas you do not have. What often appears to be a failure of structure or communication is, in various cases, a failure of idea generation at an earlier stage. Once this is understood, a number of classroom phenomena make more sense.

For example, when students struggle with writing or speaking tasks, teachers may assume that the issue lies in grammar or vocabulary. However, the problem may be that students simply do not have enough ideas to work with in the first place. Without sufficient raw material, organization becomes extremely difficult, and communication collapses before it even begins.


Brainstorming: When Idea Generation Does Not Happen

This becomes visible during brainstorming activities. When students are asked to work in groups and generate as many ideas as possible within a limited time, the results are often sparse. It is common for groups to produce only two or three ideas before stopping, even when encouraged to continue.

Part of the difficulty lies in the task’s unfamiliarity itself. Brainstorming requires students to prioritize quantity over quality and to temporarily suspend judgment. For numerous students, this runs counter to their prior learning experiences, where correctness is emphasized and mistakes are avoided. As a result, ideas are filtered too early, and the flow of thought is interrupted before it develops. What appears to be a lack of creativity is often a lack of experience with this cognitive process.


Organization and Mind Mapping: A Downstream Problem

Difficulties with organization and mind mapping are closely related. Teachers often assume that students can take a set of ideas and arrange them into a logical structure. However, if the initial pool of ideas is limited, there is very little to organize. In this sense, problems with structure are frequently downstream effects of problems with idea generation.

This also connects to the broader issue of the Transfer of Learning. Even when students encounter similar tasks across different subjects, they may not automatically apply previously learned strategies. Without explicit instruction and reinforcement, skills such as organizing information or developing arguments do not easily transfer from one context to another (Perkins & Salomon, 1992). As a result, each new task is approached as if it were entirely unfamiliar.


Study Skills: Effort Without Strategy

A related issue can be seen in students’ study habits. In conversations with high school teachers, I was often struck by how little emphasis was placed on explicitly teaching study strategies. Students were encouraged to study hard, but what this meant in practice was rarely defined.

For students, studying comprises long hours spent rereading material, memorizing vocabulary, or repeating information. While these approaches can produce short-term gains, they are often inefficient and do little to promote deeper understanding. Over time, this creates a disconnect between effort and outcome. Students invest significant time and energy, but the results are inconsistent, which leads to frustration and, sometimes, decreased motivation. From the perspective of learning theory, this reflects a reliance on surface approaches rather than more effective, deeper strategies (Biggs & Tang, 2011).


Summarization: The Missing Skill of Distillation

The inability to summarize provides another clear example of this broader issue. When students are asked to explain what a text, movie, or lecture is about, they often respond by recounting details rather than identifying main ideas. Instead of distilling information, they reproduce it.

Summarization requires the ability to prioritize, distinguish between essential and non-essential information, and compress meaning into a more concise form. These are complex skills that depend on both comprehension and organization. When they are underdeveloped, it becomes difficult for students to move beyond surface-level engagement with content. In this sense, summarization is not just a language skill. It is a key indicator of whether meaningful learning has occurred.


The Structural Gap: Missing Frameworks for Production

Across these examples, a consistent pattern emerges. Students are rarely taught clear, repeatable processes for producing ideas and communication. While considerable attention is given to vocabulary, grammar, and correct answers, far less emphasis is placed on how to generate, develop, and structure ideas.

This is particularly significant in the context of English education, where communication often relies on explicit organizational patterns such as introduction, body, and conclusion. These structures are not self-evident. They must be taught, modeled, and practiced. Without them, students are effectively being asked to produce language without having the underlying framework to support it.


Implications for English Learning

The consequences of this gap become especially visible in English classrooms. Because English communication often requires clarity of structure and logical progression, students who lack the ability to generate and organize ideas may find the language itself difficult to use effectively. What appears to be a problem of grammar or vocabulary is, in many cases, a problem of process.

As a result, English learning can become mechanical and fragmented. Students may produce correct sentences in isolation, but struggle to sustain meaningful communication. This disconnect can make progress feel slow and effortful, reinforcing the perception that English is inherently difficult.


What Teachers Can Do

If the underlying issue is procedural, then the response must also focus on process. One practical starting point is to conduct some form of needs analysis early in a course. Short writing tasks or unscripted speaking activities can provide valuable insight into what students are able to do, rather than what teachers assume they can do.

From there, it becomes important to teach processes explicitly. Tasks should be broken down into stages such as brainstorming, organizing, producing, and revising, with each stage modeled and practiced. In particular, students may need time and support to become comfortable with idea generation. Emphasizing quantity over quality in the early stages, and normalizing the presence of imperfect or incomplete ideas, can help create the conditions for more productive thinking.

Low-stakes activities also play an important role. When the pressure of evaluation is reduced, students are more willing to experiment and take risks. Over time, this can lead to greater confidence and more effective engagement with tasks. In addition, incorporating peer audiences, such as sharing work within the class, can increase motivation and encourage students to put more effort into their work.

Finally, allowing strategic use of the first language during certain stages of the process can reduce cognitive load and support idea development. The goal is not to avoid the target language, but to create a pathway that leads to more meaningful use of it.


Conclusion: Rethinking Our Assumptions

It is easy to focus on what students cannot do, particularly in language classrooms where gaps in performance are highly visible. However, a more productive question is why those gaps exist in the first place. If students struggle to brainstorm, summarize, and organize ideas, it may not be because they are unwilling or unable, but because they have never been explicitly taught how.

As teachers, there is a tendency to assume that these foundational processes are already in place. When they are not, everything built on top of them becomes more difficult. In this sense, the challenge is not simply to teach more content, but to reconsider what is taken for granted in the classroom.

A significant amount of time is spent asking students to produce language. What must be considered more carefully is whether they have been taught how to produce ideas. Until that gap is addressed, many of the difficulties encountered in the classroom will continue to persist, not because students cannot learn, but because an essential step in the learning process has been overlooked.


📚 References

Biggs, J., & Tang, C. (2011). Teaching for quality learning at university (4th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.

Perkins, D. N., & Salomon, G. (1992). Transfer of learning. International Encyclopedia of Education (2nd ed.). Pergamon Press.

Atkinson, D. (1997). A critical approach to critical thinking in TESOL. TESOL Quarterly, 31(1), 71–94.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.