Understand It Before You Use It

Understand It Before You Use It

Why thoughtful teaching requires more than following educational trends

The Attraction of a Good Idea

Education is full of new ideas, approaches, and terminology that promise to improve teaching and learning. We encounter them in professional development workshops, conference presentations, journal articles, blogs, and conversations with colleagues. Some of these ideas become widely accepted, while others disappear after a few years. Terms such as active learning, flipped learning, student-centred learning, and project-based learning have all influenced discussions about how we should teach. When we come across something that sounds promising, it is natural to start thinking about how we might incorporate it into our own classrooms. However, I sometimes wonder how much time we spend understanding these ideas before we begin using them.

There is nothing wrong with being interested in new approaches or looking for ways to improve our teaching. In fact, a willingness to question established practices and experiment with alternatives is an important part of professional development. The problem arises when we adopt an idea because it sounds good, or because it has become popular, without taking the time to understand what it involves and why it might be effective. We may recognize the terminology and have a general impression of what it means, but that is not necessarily the same as understanding the underlying principles. Before asking how we can use an idea in our classrooms, perhaps we should first ask what it actually means, where it came from, and what it is intended to accomplish.

Knowing the Label Is Not the Same as Understanding the Idea

Educational terminology can give us a false sense of understanding. We hear these terms repeatedly, see examples of them being used, and eventually become comfortable using them ourselves. Yet the same term can mean different things to different people, and our interpretation may not reflect the thinking behind the original concept. An approach that has developed through research, theory, and years of classroom practice can easily be reduced to a collection of activities that appear to represent it. Once that happens, we may be using the terminology without really applying the idea.

Consider how often teachers describe their classes as student-centred, say that they use active learning, or explain that their students regularly participate in discussions. These descriptions sound positive, but they do not tell us very much about what actually happens in the classroom. What does student-centred learning look like in practice? What makes an activity active in a meaningful sense? What should students be thinking about, producing, or learning through the experience? More importantly, why should the approach work, and what would we expect to see if it were working as intended? These are not merely academic questions. They help us decide whether an approach is appropriate for our students and whether the activities we design are likely to achieve their intended purpose.

This is why I think teachers need to look beyond the label. When we encounter an unfamiliar approach, we should investigate its background, examine the reasoning behind it, and consider what the research and professional discussion actually tell us. We may discover an idea that is more useful than we initially realized, or we may find that the popular version has lost some of the features that made it valuable in the first place. We might also discover that an approach needs to be adapted to suit our students and teaching context. The point is not to become an expert in every educational theory that comes along. It is to avoid mistaking familiarity with a term for the knowledge needed to use it thoughtfully.

The Difference Between an Activity and Learning

One of the places where this distinction becomes particularly clear is in the relationship between classroom activities and learning. Take the familiar instruction, “Discuss this with your partner.” Many of us have used it countless times, often with the intention of encouraging students to become more actively involved in a lesson. It seems straightforward enough: give students a question, ask them to talk to each other, and allow them to explore the topic before sharing their ideas with the class. However, what exactly do we mean when we ask students to discuss something? Do they know how to ask follow-up questions, explain their reasoning, build on another person’s contribution, or respectfully disagree? Do they understand what they are supposed to accomplish by the end of the conversation?

We sometimes assume that students already know how to do these things, particularly when the activity seems simple to us. Yet putting students into pairs or groups does not automatically produce meaningful interaction, any more than asking them to read something guarantees that they will understand it. Students may exchange a few comments, wait for the time to pass, or simply agree with each other without exploring the question. The activity has taken place, but that does not necessarily mean the intended learning has occurred. Student participation and student learning are related, but they are not interchangeable.

Over the years, I have encountered teachers who were looking for activities that would get their students talking more. Their intentions were good, and increasing student participation can certainly be a worthwhile goal. However, the search for another activity sometimes seemed to take precedence over examining why the existing activity was not working. If students are not engaging with a discussion task, for example, perhaps they need more support with the language or skills involved. Perhaps the question is too difficult, the purpose is unclear, or the task does not give them a genuine reason to exchange ideas. Simply introducing a different activity may not address any of these problems. We need to look at what students are actually being asked to do and consider whether the activity provides the conditions necessary for the intended learning to take place.

This is not an argument against activities, group work, or experimentation. These are important parts of teaching. Rather, it is a reminder that activities should serve a purpose beyond keeping students occupied or making a lesson appear more interactive. When we understand the principles behind an approach, we are better equipped to design appropriate tasks, recognize when something is not working, and make adjustments for the students in front of us.

Making Sure We Are on the Same Page

Understanding an educational approach is only part of the challenge. We also need to consider whether our students understand what we mean when we give them instructions or describe what we expect. Teachers regularly use words such as discuss, collaborate, participate, reflect, research, prepare, and complete as though their meanings are self-evident. In practice, however, students may interpret these words quite differently from the way we intend them. This can be especially apparent in language learning, where students are already working with unfamiliar vocabulary and instructions, but the issue is certainly not limited to language classrooms.

Take the instruction to complete an assignment. A teacher may expect students to attempt every question and make a reasonable effort, even if they are unsure of some answers. A student, on the other hand, may believe that answering three-quarters of the questions is sufficient because most of the work has been done. When the assignment is returned with a poor grade, the student may feel unfairly treated, while the teacher wonders why the student did not follow the instructions. Both may believe their expectations were perfectly reasonable, but they were not working from the same understanding of what completion meant.

We can avoid some of these misunderstandings by making our expectations explicit and checking what students understand. Rather than simply telling students to discuss a question, we can ask what makes a good discussion and work together to identify the behaviours that help one develop. Before a group project, we can talk about what effective collaboration involves and how responsibility should be shared. When assigning written work, we can examine examples of a completed assignment and discuss what makes it successful. These conversations take time, but they are not time taken away from learning. They help establish the foundation students need to participate more effectively and take greater responsibility for their work.

There is also an important benefit in giving students a voice in these discussions. When they are invited to think about expectations and contribute to a shared understanding of what successful work looks like, they become more involved in the process. This does not mean that every classroom decision must be negotiated or that the teacher gives up responsibility for setting standards. The teacher still provides direction, establishes boundaries, and makes final decisions where necessary. However, students are more likely to understand and take ownership of expectations when they have had an opportunity to think about them rather than simply being told what to do.

Making Standards Visible

This idea connects naturally to the use of rubrics and peer assessment. Rubrics are often treated primarily as grading tools, a way for teachers to assign marks consistently and explain how an assignment will be evaluated. They can serve that purpose, but they can also help students understand what quality looks like before they begin working. Instead of presenting a rubric as a list of requirements that students must satisfy, we can use it as the starting point for a discussion about the characteristics of effective work. What makes a presentation clear and engaging? What makes an argument convincing? What distinguishes a thoughtful response from one that simply repeats information?

This can open the door to peer assessment. Once students have a clearer understanding of the criteria, peer assessment can become a meaningful part of the evaluation process. Students are no longer relying entirely on personal preference or making vague judgments about whether they liked a classmate’s work. They have shared standards to guide their observations and feedback. In my experience, students can sometimes be stricter when evaluating their classmates than I would be myself, but that is another reason to discuss the criteria and expectations carefully. The purpose is not simply to have students grade each other or reduce the teacher’s workload. It is to encourage them to look closely at the work, identify strengths and weaknesses, and think about what makes it effective.

This process can also encourage students to reflect on their own work. When they examine another person’s presentation, report, or project, they may recognize things they could have done differently themselves. Assessment becomes part of the learning process rather than something that happens only after the work is finished. For the teacher, it provides another opportunity to see how students understand the standards and where further instruction may be needed. Again, the value comes not from introducing a technique because it is associated with a particular teaching approach, but from understanding what the technique can accomplish and using it with a clear purpose.

Sometimes, It Really Is About Semantics

I have a particular interest in the language teachers use, and I realize that some of these distinctions may sound like little more than semantics. Does it really matter whether we describe something as teaching or learning, or whether we spend time defining what we mean by participation or completion? I would argue that it does, because the words we use often reflect the assumptions we bring to the classroom, and those assumptions influence the choices we make.

For example, teaching and learning are closely connected, but they are not the same thing. If we think of teaching primarily as delivering information, we may judge a lesson by how clearly we explained the material or how much content we managed to cover. If we focus on learning, we also need to consider what students do with that information: how they make sense of it, apply it, question it, discuss it, and use it to produce something of their own. The teacher still has an important role in explaining concepts and providing guidance, but the purpose is to create opportunities for students to do the work of learning rather than simply receive information.

This distinction matters because our understanding of teaching influences how we plan lessons, choose activities, and evaluate success. A busy classroom is not necessarily an effective classroom, just as a quiet classroom is not necessarily an ineffective one. What matters is whether students are engaging with the material in ways that help them achieve the intended learning goals. Once again, the terminology is only useful if it helps us think more clearly about what we are trying to accomplish.

The Value of Clarifying the Little Things

Not every misunderstanding involves a major educational theory or a complicated teaching method. Sometimes, a small clarification can make a substantial difference to how students approach their work. One example from my own teaching is the distinction between soft and hard deadlines. Many of my students were often quite poor at managing their time, so we had a discussion about deadlines and how to set a soft deadline. The hard deadline is the actual due date for an assignment. The soft deadline is a personal target set earlier, giving students some breathing room if something unexpected happens or if they need extra time to resolve a problem.

The idea is simple, but it encourages students to think differently about planning and time management. Instead of treating the official deadline as the point at which they should begin worrying about finishing, they can work towards an earlier target and leave themselves some flexibility. In end-of-course reflections, students told me that they appreciated being introduced to this idea because it had helped them manage their work in other courses as well. Some had carried the practice beyond my classroom, which was a particularly satisfying outcome. A brief explanation of a concept, followed by a practical way to apply it, had given them something they could continue using independently.

Examples like this remind me that teachers do not need to turn every lesson into a discussion of educational theory. What matters is recognizing when students may be operating with assumptions that differ from our own and taking the time to clarify what we mean. Whether we are explaining an assignment, teaching students how to collaborate, establishing assessment criteria, or introducing a new approach to learning, a little more attention to shared understanding can prevent confusion and help students become more independent.

Understand It Before You Use It

The next time we encounter an appealing teaching idea or a new educational trend, perhaps we should resist the temptation to immediately incorporate it into our next lesson. Instead, we can begin by asking what the idea actually means, where it came from, what problem it was intended to address, and what it requires of both teachers and students. We can also take some time to consider what evidence or reasoning supports it, how it might work in our particular context, and what we would look for to determine whether it is helping. Another consideration that is frequently overlooked is whether our students understand what we are asking them to do and whether we have given them the support they need to do it successfully.

None of this requires us to become specialists in every new approach or spend weeks researching every classroom activity. It simply requires a willingness to look beyond the label, question our assumptions, and reflect on the relationship between what we intend to teach and what students actually experience. Sometimes that reflection will lead us to adopt a new approach, sometimes it can help us improve something we already do, and sometimes it may reveal that a popular idea is not particularly useful for our students or our teaching goals.

Good teaching is not about collecting techniques or following trends. It is about making thoughtful choices based on an understanding of what we are trying to accomplish and the needs of the students in our classrooms. New ideas can be valuable sources of inspiration, but they should be starting points for reflection rather than ready-made solutions. Before we use an idea, we should understand it well enough to decide whether it belongs in our classroom, how it should be applied, and how we will know whether it is making a difference.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.