If you teach students who have grown up with smartphones, social media, streaming video, and constant access to the internet, you have probably experienced this situation. You introduce a new digital tool and expect students to figure it out quickly. After all, they are digital natives. They have grown up with technology. Surely they know how to use it.
Sometimes they do.
Sometimes they really do not.
This is one of the assumptions about today’s students that I have become increasingly cautious about. Students may be highly comfortable with the digital technologies they use every day while having surprisingly little experience using technology for productive, creative, or unfamiliar purposes.
There is an important distinction here. Being surrounded by technology is not the same as being digitally literate.
The Digital Native Myth
The term digital native was popularized by Marc Prensky in the early 2000s to describe a generation that had grown up surrounded by digital technology. The idea was attractive because it seemed to explain something that many teachers and parents were observing. Young people appeared to interact with computers, mobile phones, and the internet naturally, while older adults often needed to learn these technologies more deliberately.
However, the concept has been heavily criticized. Research has found little evidence for the idea that an entire generation possesses a distinctive set of technological skills simply because they grew up with digital devices. Bennett, Maton, and Kervin (2008), for example, questioned both the evidence behind the digital native concept and the assumption that young people form a homogeneous group of technologically sophisticated learners. Eynon (2020) similarly argues that the digital native concept persists despite weak evidence and can be problematic when it leads educators to underestimate the support young people need.
This is important because there is a difference between using technology frequently and understanding how to use technology effectively.
Put a smartphone in the hands of a teenager and they will probably know what to do. They can open an app, search for something, watch a video, send a message, take a photograph, or navigate social media without needing much instruction.
Now put that same student in front of an unfamiliar computer and ask them to create a folder structure, organize files, download and locate documents, manipulate a spreadsheet, learn unfamiliar software, or troubleshoot a problem. The picture can change considerably.
This should not really surprise us. Most modern digital products have been deliberately designed to be easy to use. The consumer does not need to understand how the technology works. If an application is too complicated, there are plenty of alternatives. We can simply move on.
That is very different from learning to use technology as a tool.
Consumers Are Not Necessarily Creators
Much of what we see young people doing with technology is consumption. They watch videos, listen to music, follow social media accounts, play games, communicate with friends, and search for information. Some students are certainly highly skilled creators, programmers, designers, video producers, or content creators. However, we should not assume that these students represent everyone in their generation.
A student may be highly proficient with the technologies they use regularly while having difficulty transferring those skills to an unfamiliar context. This is not unique to young people. Adults do exactly the same thing. Someone can be extremely competent using the software required for their job and then struggle when asked to use an unfamiliar application.
Digital competence is therefore not simply a matter of age. It develops through experience, exposure, purpose, and practice.
Research supports this distinction. Ng (2012), for example, found that students could develop digital literacy but still needed opportunities to understand and use technology for educational purposes. More recent work has similarly emphasized that digital competence needs to be developed rather than assumed (González-Mujico, 2024).
This matches what I found in my own doctoral research. My study of Japanese university students’ digital literacy and perceptions of digital tools suggested that students were not necessarily resistant to technology. Rather, they needed a reason to use unfamiliar tools, along with appropriate scaffolding and opportunities to become familiar with them (Cochrane, 2022).
Once they understood what they could actually do with the technology, their willingness to explore it changed.
That experience changed the way I think about students and technology. Instead of asking, “Why do these students not know how to use this?” I am more likely to ask, “When have they ever had a reason to learn this?”
That is a much more useful question.
From Consumption to Production
There is another issue that concerns me about our increasingly digital environment.
Young people have access to an extraordinary amount of content. If something does not immediately interest them, another video, website, game, or social media post is only seconds away. The technology makes it very easy to move on.
I do not want to turn this into another argument about how things were better when I was young. They were not necessarily better. They were simply different.
When I was growing up, entertainment often required some effort. We had a limited number of television channels. If we wanted music, we listened to the radio or bought records. If we wanted information, we went to a library or found a book. We played sports, learned musical instruments, built things, collected things, or found other ways to occupy ourselves.
Today, much of that effort has been removed. Again, this is not necessarily bad. The problem arises when we confuse easy access to content with the ability to engage deeply with it. Students need opportunities to move from consumption to production.
Instead of simply finding the first useful-looking result in a search engine, they can be asked to investigate a question using multiple sources. Instead of asking an AI tool to produce a report, they can research, take notes, compare information, develop their own ideas, produce drafts, receive feedback, and explain the decisions they made along the way.
This is particularly important now that generative AI can produce apparently polished answers in seconds. Recent research on assessment in higher education is increasingly questioning whether traditional output-focused assignments provide enough evidence of what students actually know and can do (Weng et al., 2024; Xia et al., 2024).
The answer is not simply to ban AI. It is to design learning that requires students to think, make decisions, document their processes, and demonstrate their development.
That is a very different use of technology.
Technology Does Not Have to Be Entertaining
This brings me to something I think teachers need to be particularly careful about.
I am not arguing that teaching should be boring. Far from it. However, I am equally uncomfortable with the idea that technology should be used primarily to make learning entertaining.
There is a temptation to introduce a new app, game, video, or interactive activity because it will “motivate” students. Sometimes it will. There is nothing wrong with students enjoying what they are doing, but enjoyment should not be the primary learning objective.
A good learning task can be enjoyable because students become engaged in it. They can experience social engagement through collaboration, cognitive engagement through solving a problem, and a sense of accomplishment when they successfully produce something that initially seemed difficult. That kind of enjoyment is different from entertainment.
A challenging project may not be particularly enjoyable during the first twenty minutes. Students may struggle with the technology, disagree with their group members, or become frustrated when something does not work.
Then they solve the problem.
That moment of accomplishment can be much more meaningful than simply giving students another entertaining activity.
This is one of the principles behind my own approach to production-oriented learning. In the Sandwich Production Method, for example, students begin by producing something, encounter authentic examples and feedback, reflect on their work, and then produce an improved version (Cochrane & Cochrane, 2023). The technology can support that process, but it is not the reason for the process.
The purpose comes first. The technology comes second.
Keep the Challenge, Provide the Support
This also connects to the increasingly common discussion about student attention spans. I am cautious about claims that young people have somehow lost the ability to concentrate. The evidence is more complicated than that, and blaming students does not help us much.
What I do think we need to consider is whether students have sufficient opportunities to practice sustained attention on tasks where the reward is not immediate. That is a skill, and like other skills, it can be developed.
Longer projects can provide opportunities for students to develop this ability. A research project, for example, does not need to be completed in one enormous assignment. Students can choose a topic, develop questions, find sources, take notes, organize information, produce a draft, receive feedback, revise their work, and present the final product.
Breaking the project into stages provides structure without removing the challenge. It also creates opportunities for lower-stakes assessment along the way. Rather than assigning all of the marks to the final product, teachers can assess the research question, notes, source evaluation, draft, peer feedback, revision, and final presentation. These stages provide opportunities for peer and class feedback and discussion while making the learning process more visible.
This approach can also be useful in an age of generative AI. When teachers are interested in the process as well as the final product, students have more reason to engage with the stages of the task. Recent research on assessment in the age of generative AI is increasingly pointing toward greater emphasis on process, critical thinking, self-regulation, and authentic applications of knowledge (Weng et al., 2024; Xia et al., 2024).
However, there is a danger when students struggle with these kinds of tasks. There is a temptation to make the task easier. Sometimes that is appropriate. If students genuinely lack the prerequisite knowledge or skills, we need to provide support. Good scaffolding is not about throwing students into the deep end and expecting them to swim.
Support is not the same as lowering standards.
Students who have spent much of their educational experience answering questions with known answers may have relatively little experience with open-ended, productive work. Asking them to investigate a problem, make decisions, collaborate, revise, and create something original can therefore be uncomfortable. They may complain, especially when they encounter unfamiliar technology or realize that there is no single set of instructions telling them exactly what to do.
That does not necessarily mean the task is too difficult.
My experience has been that students will sometimes complain while completing a challenging project and then report a strong sense of satisfaction and accomplishment once it is finished. They have discovered that they can do something that initially seemed beyond their ability. If we continually remove the difficult parts of a task whenever students struggle, we also remove some of the opportunity for them to develop independence and confidence.
The teacher’s role is to make the challenge achievable without removing the challenge itself. Break a complex task into manageable stages. Provide examples and discuss possible approaches. Give students clear instructions and rubrics. Check their progress and provide feedback individually, in groups, or with the whole class. Most importantly, assess and teach the digital skills they actually need for the task rather than assuming that they already possess them.
At the same time, I do not think the answer is for the teacher to demonstrate every click or provide a prescribed workflow for every situation. Students need opportunities to make decisions about how they will approach a task and to discover solutions for themselves. We can introduce tools, demonstrate possibilities, suggest workflows, and then gradually step back as students become more capable.
This also means that we do not always have to know the answer.
There have been plenty of occasions when a student has shown me a tool or technique that I did not know. Rather than seeing this as a threat to my authority as a teacher, I see it as an opportunity to model something important: we do not have to know everything before we begin. When we encounter a problem with technology, we can work through it together.
Vygotsky’s (1978) concept of the more knowledgeable other is useful here. The teacher does not have to know everything. Our role is to provide the guidance and support that helps learners move beyond what they can currently do independently. In a technological environment that changes constantly, learning how to solve unfamiliar problems may be more valuable than simply learning the “correct” way to use a particular application.
The goal is not to make learning easy. It is to make challenging learning possible.
Finding the Balance
So, are today’s students digital natives?
Perhaps the better question is: What can our students actually do with technology? Can they evaluate sources, organize information, learn unfamiliar tools, solve problems, collaborate, and create something rather than simply consume it?
Their digital skills vary considerably, and their ability to use technology effectively for learning needs to be developed rather than assumed (Bennett et al., 2008; Eynon, 2020). Our role is not to compete with students’ technological abilities or become experts in every new application. We can provide the support they need, give them reasons to use technology, and gradually expect them to take greater responsibility for how they use those tools.
Technology is a tool. Use it when it supports the learning goal and use analogue approaches when they make more sense. Let students create rather than simply consume. Give them opportunities to work through challenging tasks, and do not be afraid to learn from them when you encounter technology you do not know.
Students may be digital consumers. Our job is to help them become digital producers, thinkers, creators, and problem-solvers.
References
Bennett, S., Maton, K., & Kervin, L. (2008). The ‘digital natives’ debate: A critical review of the evidence. British Journal of Educational Technology, 39(5), 775–786. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8535.2007.00793.x
Cochrane, R. (2022). A case study examining Japanese university students’ digital literacy and perceptions of digital tools for academic English learning [Doctoral dissertation, Lancaster University]. https://doi.org/10.17635/lancaster/thesis/1557
Cochrane, R., & Cochrane, Y. (2023). The Sandwich Production Method: Shifting the paradigm from passive to productive. OnCUE Journal, 15(1), 68–81.
Eynon, R. (2020). The myth of the digital native: Why it persists and the harm it inflicts. In Education in the digital age. OECD Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1787/1209166a-en
González-Mujico, F. de L. (2024). Measuring student and educator digital competence beyond self-assessment: Developing and validating two rubric-based frameworks. Education and Information Technologies, 29, 13299–13324. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10639-023-12363-7
Ng, W. (2012). Can we teach digital natives digital literacy? Computers & Education, 59(3), 1065–1078. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compedu.2012.04.016
Vygotsky, L. S. (1978). Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes. Harvard University Press.
Weng, X., Xia, Q., Gu, M., Rajaram, K., & Chiu, T. K. F. (2024). Assessment and learning outcomes for generative AI in higher education: A scoping review on current research status and trends. Australasian Journal of Educational Technology, 40(6), 37–55. https://doi.org/10.14742/ajet.9540
Xia, Q., Weng, X., Ouyang, F., Lin, T. J., & Chiu, T. K. F. (2024). A scoping review on how generative artificial intelligence transforms assessment in higher education. International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education, 21, Article 40. https://doi.org/10.1186/s41239-024-00468-z






Leave a Reply